Better communication
I recently got into a discussion(argument) about the validity of having a blog to display topical information in an easy manner rather than just using a wiki.
My point being that the discussion tabs on a wiki are tedious to use and everything just runs together. The discussion tabs were not designed for presenting topical information so much as comments from other wiki users about edits to a project and aren't really suitable for proper discussion either. You wind up having to use nested bullets and leave timestamped signatures, which the user has to put there by clicking a button mind you rather than it being a transparent action.
The opposition has taken a few stances on the matter:
- user1: "i simply like forums for discussions...those are my feeling"
- user2: "the whole blog-in-a-wiki idea sounds rather lame too. we have discussion tabs and this irc channel"
- user2: "there's slim to no chance of me using either a blog or a forum"
While I am inclined to agree with user1 that forums are good to discussion, I can't help but feel that they're antiquated. Merely an attempt by BBS folks to maintain an old tradition in a new medium that replaced them. Not to mention I know of no secure forum packages out there. In many ways the blog replaced the forum, but as someone else pointed out they do put more emphasis on the "first post" and less on comments. Given this, blogs are better at topical information, but less so for open discussion. We might have to bite the bullet and use both, a forum for open discussion and a blog for topical information. The wiki I believe should just be used for documentation.
As far as user2's notions, I would like to point out that they also don't use the discussion tabs on the wiki, so does it really matter. While antiquated, I like IRC and I think it's a valid method of realtime discussion with other people. It's problem however is data retention in a useful manner. Yes you can log it, but it's all text and not as easy to search through as a blog or forum would be. IRC might be a good way of keeping the flames out on the forum though, who knows.
Keep in mind that all this was over IRC.

